Comments on: Internet2 users being targeted by RIAA and MPAA http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa News from the Tech and IT World Wed, 25 Nov 2009 13:03:06 -0700 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.6 hourly 1 By: nikolaos http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa#comment-11976 nikolaos Sat, 20 May 2006 12:33:15 +0000 http://news.techwhack.com/1120/13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa/#comment-11976 Chris (the artist), It is obvious from your words that you still live mentally in medieval ages because of the way you perceive art: as a privilege, very much like works of art were perceived in the past. You are a plutocrat. Therefore I understand it is hard for you to accept that the internet stands for sharing. You obviously want to exploit it for your own personal well being. Great artists do not mind at all the sharing, on the contrary. Since you are not a great artist, you DO mind it because your *art* is really your source of income (work) and not true art. If you were a true artist you wouldn't care one bit about your well being, because you would understand that you are the medium of something bigger than you. Have some Humility. Tada Chris (the artist),

It is obvious from your words that you still live mentally in medieval ages because of the way you perceive art: as a privilege, very much like works of art were perceived in the past. You are a plutocrat.
Therefore I understand it is hard for you to accept that the internet stands for sharing. You obviously want to exploit it for your own personal well being.

Great artists do not mind at all the sharing, on the contrary. Since you are not a great artist, you DO mind it because your *art* is really your source of income (work) and not true art. If you were a true artist you wouldn’t care one bit about your well being, because you would understand that you are the medium of something bigger than you. Have some Humility.

Tada

]]> By: thekidsintheway http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa#comment-4803 thekidsintheway Sun, 18 Dec 2005 03:40:13 +0000 http://news.techwhack.com/1120/13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa/#comment-4803 Everything you people are saying goes both ways. First, "art is meant to be shared. ri/mp/aa seems to not wish to share. this stuff is therefore not art. they are, therefore not protecting artists." apparently you have never created a work of art before. It takes lots and lots of time, and if I'm not mistaken, time is money. Second, the RIAA and MPAA are not losing a substantial amount of money to this cause, but is 20 dollars to go buy a movie really all that much; or how about 10-15 for a C.D. If you kids just go out and get a part time job you'll have that in half a day's work. Oh wait, you're 30 and work for some huge corporation, then you better have the money to spare out of your 40-80 thousand dollar a year sallary. Lastly, movies and music are a form of art, myself being a musician couldn't agree with that more; however, they are also a form of entertainment. Entertainment isn't supposed to be free. It is a priveledge that you must work hard to achieve. That's all the ranting I have for now. Chris. Everything you people are saying goes both ways. First, “art is meant to be shared. ri/mp/aa seems to not wish to share. this stuff is therefore not art. they are, therefore not protecting artists.” apparently you have never created a work of art before. It takes lots and lots of time, and if I’m not mistaken, time is money. Second, the RIAA and MPAA are not losing a substantial amount of money to this cause, but is 20 dollars to go buy a movie really all that much; or how about 10-15 for a C.D. If you kids just go out and get a part time job you’ll have that in half a day’s work. Oh wait, you’re 30 and work for some huge corporation, then you better have the money to spare out of your 40-80 thousand dollar a year sallary. Lastly, movies and music are a form of art, myself being a musician couldn’t agree with that more; however, they are also a form of entertainment. Entertainment isn’t supposed to be free. It is a priveledge that you must work hard to achieve. That’s all the ranting I have for now.

Chris.

]]> By: Black Flag http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa#comment-1807 Black Flag Wed, 13 Apr 2005 20:12:16 +0000 http://news.techwhack.com/1120/13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa/#comment-1807 Last album I bought was before that Celine Dion copy protection story. And the prices they sell an album for... I remember paying the price of two beers for an album. This was loong ago, when music was comming on tapes. And as the price increased the double tape recorder made its entrance on the market. And not that long ago the records guys sued Diamond for the mp3 player. Last album I bought was before that Celine Dion copy protection story. And the prices they sell an album for… I remember paying the price of two beers for an album. This was loong ago, when music was comming on tapes. And as the price increased the double tape recorder made its entrance on the market. And not that long ago the records guys sued Diamond for the mp3 player.

]]> By: Deej http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa#comment-1804 Deej Wed, 13 Apr 2005 19:37:15 +0000 http://news.techwhack.com/1120/13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa/#comment-1804 When a buisness model exists to use file swapping networks as a revenue source, then I have less of a problem with file sharing if it forces our hand. Wait what buisness model you ask? Well just because the RIAA is to antiquated to see it, does not mean it doesn't exist. If every ISP collected just 5 dollars from every internet broadband user, and associated this money as an allowance toward P2P downloading, then the RIAA could use P2P as a ranking system for distribution of that revenue to the artist. At least then they could recover the loss of money (which is completely subjective and has been recently proven to be less substantial then they make it out to be)through a constant revenue stream. Who wouldn't pay an extra five bucks for a license to continue downloading? Do the math and prove to me a better way to solve this delema. I for one buy the CD for more then the music, and don't buy crap just because of one overly popped song. Done venting for now... P.S. If I can think of this (and I AM an idiot) why can't an entire corporation full of "smart" people? You might want to ask that question yourself. When a buisness model exists to use file swapping networks as a revenue source, then I have less of a problem with file sharing if it forces our hand. Wait what buisness model you ask? Well just because the RIAA is to antiquated to see it, does not mean it doesn’t exist. If every ISP collected just 5 dollars from every internet broadband user, and associated this money as an allowance toward P2P downloading, then the RIAA could use P2P as a ranking system for distribution of that revenue to the artist. At least then they could recover the loss of money (which is completely subjective and has been recently proven to be less substantial then they make it out to be)through a constant revenue stream. Who wouldn’t pay an extra five bucks for a license to continue downloading? Do the math and prove to me a better way to solve this delema. I for one buy the CD for more then the music, and don’t buy crap just because of one overly popped song.

Done venting for now…

P.S. If I can think of this (and I AM an idiot) why can’t an entire corporation full of “smart” people? You might want to ask that question yourself.

]]> By: Andrew http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa#comment-1802 Andrew Wed, 13 Apr 2005 19:28:41 +0000 http://news.techwhack.com/1120/13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa/#comment-1802 I am against illegal file sharing but RIAA, MPAA and similar organizations shouldn't be allowed to hinder technological advancements. The world needs technology...not films and music!! I am against illegal file sharing but RIAA, MPAA and similar organizations shouldn’t be allowed to hinder technological advancements. The world needs technology…not films and music!!

]]> By: Nic Stage http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa#comment-1801 Nic Stage Wed, 13 Apr 2005 19:27:01 +0000 http://news.techwhack.com/1120/13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa/#comment-1801 The collapse of one econoic system doesn't necessarily mean that a new economic system will not form (unfortunately, imho). These media companies aren't concerned at all about the economic system; they are concerned about <i>their</i> business. The collapse of one econoic system doesn’t necessarily mean that a new economic system will not form (unfortunately, imho). These media companies aren’t concerned at all about the economic system; they are concerned about their business.

]]> By: who? http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa#comment-1800 who? Wed, 13 Apr 2005 19:23:00 +0000 http://news.techwhack.com/1120/13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa/#comment-1800 art is meant to be shared. ri/mp/aa seems to not wish to share. this stuff is therefore not art. they are, therefore not protecting artists. art is meant to be shared. ri/mp/aa seems to not wish to share. this stuff is therefore not art. they are, therefore not protecting artists.

]]> By: RBD http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa#comment-1799 RBD Wed, 13 Apr 2005 19:22:13 +0000 http://news.techwhack.com/1120/13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa/#comment-1799 If your not part of the solution, your part of the problem. Suing someone has already proved to not be a real worthwhile or meaningfull deterrant due to probably the moderate/high turn around in some of these colleges. If 30 billion dollars a year aint enough to get by on then maybe you need to rethink your marketing and spending strategies and leave our childrens college funds alone. If your not part of the solution, your part of the problem. Suing someone has already proved to not be a real worthwhile or meaningfull deterrant due to probably the moderate/high turn around in some of these colleges. If 30 billion dollars a year aint enough to get by on then maybe you need to rethink your marketing and spending strategies and leave our childrens college funds alone.

]]> By: Bob http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa#comment-1798 Bob Wed, 13 Apr 2005 19:20:54 +0000 http://news.techwhack.com/1120/13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa/#comment-1798 The perpetually greedy movie industry. Instead of going after people they need to figure out a way to work with them. The perpetually greedy movie industry. Instead of going after people they need to figure out a way to work with them.

]]> By: Jacques http://news.techwhack.com/1120-13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa#comment-1797 Jacques Wed, 13 Apr 2005 19:17:04 +0000 http://news.techwhack.com/1120/13042005-internet2-users-being-targeted-by-riaa-and-mpaa/#comment-1797 If illegitimate business is allowed to flourish, the whole ecenomic system will collapse. If illegitimate business is allowed to flourish, the whole ecenomic system will collapse.

]]>